I hope you won't mind if I blow my firms trumpet a bit?

Some of you may recall that a couple of weeks ago I asked if anyone had an Aprilia scooter that I could borrow for a reconstruction I was doing, and many of you will have read in the past my views on using claims management companies or legal expenses appointed solicitors in the event that you are unfortunate enough to have a crash.

On this basis, I thought you might be interested in the case for which I was looking for the scooter, which in any case we settled last week. The case as you will read is over 10 years old because just such a firm sat on the case for 6 years and did nothing bar the basics and issue proceedings to protect the claimants rights. We took over the case and had to fight the young riders corner, now thankfully with the right result.

What has made this case interesting is that it has set a bit of case law. The third party made an offer. The case went to trial to determine values. The third party then tried to make it a requirement that the claimant be subjected to a medical examination every 5 years to establish whether the payments could be reduced.

However, this was not included in what is called the Part 36, and despite legal arguments, the Judge ruled that conditions to a part 36 could not be amended once it went trial

Anyway, as I hope you can appreciate, we are pretty pleased with this result after the claimant and his mother lost hope with the previous firm who were representing them, and I thought I would share it with you.

**Injured motorcyclist awarded £3.6 million

A 26-year-old man from south London, who had been an aspiring Premier League footballer, was last week awarded £3.6 million in compensation by the High Court, following a motorcycle accident that occurred ten years ago.

The man, who does not wish to be named and is otherwise referred to as Mr X, was involved in a head-on collision in 2002 while riding his scooter in Thornton Heath. The then 16-year-old was hit by a van being driven by Christopher Evans who had failed to notice the oncoming motorcyclist while attempting to make a right turn.

Mr X sustained multiple injuries in the collision, including a fractured right femur, fractures to both wrists, his right elbow and right ankle. He later developed chronic pain and psychological disorders, including severe Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, a Major Depressive Disorder and severe Obsessive Compulsive Disorder. He also sustained a brain injury with resulting cognitive, behavioural and emotional difficulties, personality changes, heightened fatigue and persisting headaches.

The combination of Mr X’s physical and mental conditions made it impossible for him to return to Coulsdon College, where he had previously been studying for a qualification in Business Studies. The talented footballer also had to give up any hope of playing for the Premier League football team he had had trials with. He has since been unable to contemplate employment, and is dependent on his mother for round-the-clock care.

The High Court ordered that Mr X’s award of £3.6 million was to be paid partly as a lump sum of £2.05 million, and partly by annual payments for the remainder of his life. It will be managed by his professional Deputy, Nicola Manning of McMillan Williams Solicitors who has been appointed by the Court of Protection.

Mr X’s solicitor, Phillip Scarles of McMillan Williams, who specialise in dealing with motorcycle accidents and took over the case from another law firm, said: “Not only did Mr X sustain severe orthopaedic injuries and develop chronic pain, he also developed severe psychological disorders. His mother’s care for him in very difficult living circumstances has been outstanding. This award will enable Mr X to move with his family to a home that will be much more suitable and will enhance his quality of life as much as possible.” **

very bad story, very good ending. thanks for sharing. :slight_smile:

Well done T.C. Great to hear about your good work paying off :slight_smile:

glad you got a result for the lad, sounds horrid.

Great job T.C.

Well done TC and thanks for sharing this story. I know that nothing will compensate for the loss of the young man’s quality of life, career and education, but at least this award will ensure he is well provided for.

Won’t say it’s a nice story, it isn’t, it’s a horrible one.

Well done for getting the lad a half decent amount of compensation but what really annoys me is why the heck does it take 10 years? On the assumption it is the other legal team dragging things out - that really is appalling behaviour. (stand to be corrected if it isn’t that reason)

Hope the cash will enable the guy to improve his life though sadly it seems his life will never be the same, irrespective of the payout.


+1 on the other comments.

With regard to the case law set on the Part 36 issue, do you have a link to a judgement or anything? I’m not a solicitor (i just like law) and understand the basic concepts of P36 but would be interested to read a bit more about it. Ta.

Thats excellent news Tony !!!

Well done to you guys,

I know money doesnt solve everything and he will never get those 10 years back but am sure it will go a long way to helping the fella and his family in the future.

Sounds like you put in a lot of work to get a result for them.

Sad for the guy and his family that they had to wait so long for recompense but that is certainly a good pay out.

You know I am probably the only person here who does, but I would love to know what arguments they presented for amending a Part 36 offer?

As I understand these matters, and it is limited in this regard, they make a part 36 offer, you accept the offer, but because of the age or mental difficulties of the claimant, the court is required to agree any amount. See it a lot with infant settlement cases in the County Court for very minor accidents.

If this is how things have happened how can you amend an offer after it has been accepted, what grounds could they possibly have put forward for that?

Well done mate. Hard work does pay off… You’ve just changed someone’s life.